MenaSmart Lens

Urban Maturity Framework

Initializing
GCC · MENA Urban Intelligence

We benchmark
the future
of cities

A standards-based urban-maturity benchmarking tool for municipal consultants, city planners and government stakeholders. Score a city across five standards-aligned dimensions, resolve its maturity level, and generate stakeholder-ready advisories — while keeping sensitive municipal data under your control.

Evaluation pillars

5 standards-aligned dimensions

How it works

3 steps
1

Assess

Name the city, then move through the five pillars, scoring each measure 1–5 with standard-cited guidance a tap away.

2

Analyse

See the live maturity level, radar, pillar contribution, strengths & gaps and a measure heatmap on the dashboard.

3

Report

Commit to your portfolio and export a backup or a stakeholder-ready report.

About MenaSmart Lens

MenaSmart Lens is an urban-maturity benchmarking studio for GCC and MENA municipalities. It scores a city across five standards-aligned dimensions, resolves an ITU-T-style maturity level, and generates stakeholder-ready advisories — with assessments kept under your control in local or cloud mode.

Standards basis

ISO 37122:2019 · smart city indicators ISO 37120:2018 · city services ISO 37123:2019 · resilient cities ISO 37106:2018 · smart operating model ISO 37156:2020 · data exchange ISO/IEC TS 27570:2020 · privacy ISO/TS 37107:2019 · maturity model ISO 37153:2017 · maturity assessment ITU-T Y.4903 / U4SSC · KPI methodology ITU-T Y.4904 · maturity model
Framework status — under review. The scoring rubrics and level definitions are being aligned clause-by-clause against the source standards. Figures in this build are the working model, not yet a certified framework. This tool provides benchmarking guidance, not a compliance certification.

Data & residency

The studio runs in one of two modes. The status banner (top-right) always states which.

Local mode

No cloud configured. Data is written only to this browser — zero external transmission. The sovereign, offline-safe choice for residency-sensitive client data. No login required.

Cloud mode

Supabase-backed, protected by real login and per-user row-level security for multi-device access. This project's region is ap-south-1 (Mumbai, IN) — not a GCC-sovereign region. Use Local mode for residency-sensitive data.

Assessment subject

0.0 / 5.0

Assessment journey

0 / 5 pillars · 0% complete

City maturity assessment

Pillar 1 of 5
Use the journey above to move between pillars · score each measure 1 = nascent · 5 = optimized · tap ⓘ for guidance

Saved on this device

AIExecutive insight

Regional benchmark

15 dot size = overall score
Regional ranking

Maturity readout

ITU-T Y.4904 · 5-level model
0.0
/ 5.0
L1 · Ad-hoc Silos
Score the pillars to resolve the city's maturity level.

Dimension profile

Radar

Maturity fingerprint

Every measure · spoke length = score

Each spoke is one measure, grouped into its pillar; the length is its score, so unfilled space shows exactly where the city is hollow.

Tactical advisory log

MENA-specific

Pillar contribution

Weighted share of the overall score

Strengths & gaps

Across all measures
Top strengths
Priority gaps

Measure heatmap

Every measure · shaded by score
LowerHigherNot scored

Scenario simulator

What would it take?

Model an investment scenario — drag any measure and the projected score, level and dimension profile update live. This never changes your saved assessment.

Projected overall
Auto-plan the cheapest path to…

City comparison

Select up to 4 saved cities
Select saved cities above to compare.

Generate report

Subject ·

Produces the full assessment report — cover, executive summary, dimension scorecard, radar, measure heatmap, prioritised recommendations and the measure appendix. Any cities ticked under City comparison above are included as a peer-comparison section with their own radar.

Historical archive

· 0 record(s) · Local

Your assessments are private. Use ⇧ Submit to send one to the admin for review; once the admin approves it (☆→★) it joins the shared Repository that all signed-in users can see.

CityCountryYearScoreLevelStatusActions
No records yet. Commit an assessment to populate the archive.

Administrative tools

Portability · reporting

Submissions & shared repository

Admin only · moderation

Users Submit their assessments for review here. Approve one to publish it to the shared Repository that every signed-in user can see; Decline to send it back. You can also remove or delete any record. (These same actions are available per-row in the Portfolio tab.)


Removes the seeded demo cities (unowned rows). Real user assessments are never touched.

Pillar weights

Admin only · final-score weighting

Set how much each pillar counts toward the overall score. Equal weights (1) give a simple average; raise a pillar to make it matter more.


Assessment questions

Admin only · shared with all users

Add or remove the measures scored in each pillar, and cite the standard or clause each measure comes from (e.g. ISO 37122 §23.4). Changes update everyone's assessment form and reports. Existing saved assessments keep their scores; a removed measure's old score is simply ignored.

Pillar details
Measures & weights

Sign in

Session required to access the studio

No account? Create one